My top ten fics on AO3 based on hit count:
1)
Black As Night Supernatural, Dean/Cas (2043): Dean patches Castiel up after a fight and things get a little out of control. Wing!Kink.
2)
Learn Your Body Like a Nursery Rhyme in Braille Supernatural, Dean/Cas (1790): Dean's been trying forever to convince Castiel to let out his wings during sex. His persistence is about to be rewarded.
3)
Outrun My Gun Supernatural, Dean/Cas Time Travel AU (1680): "The two of you are so stubborn you've made Heaven blink." Finally convinced that Sam and Dean will never say yes and accept their destinies, Heaven and Hell come up with a new plan, one that will redraw the Apocalypse and make everything run much more smoothly. All they need is Dean Winchester's soul.
4)
...And Into The Fire Supernatural, Dean/Cas (1469): Dean and Castiel may not have been getting along all that well as of late, but when the fighting in Heaven goes bad and Cas asks for help Dean can't say no.
5)
Look, Up In The Sky Supernatural, Dean/Cas Superhero AU (1431): In this exciting issue we cast our eyes on the mysterious metropolis of Lawrence City, and its two valiant protectors, strangers from another world striving to save the helpless citizens from the most dire threats imaginable! As threats mount from without and within, can these two unlikely partners overcome their differences in time to defeat the deadliest enemy they've ever faced? Or in a world where smoke can dress itself in human skin, can this tale only end in tragedy? Face Front, True Believers, and find out!
6)
Needle And Thread Supernatural, Dean/Cas (1308): The plan didn't go exactly how Castiel thought it would. Hurt/Comfort wing!fic.
7)
Carve Your Name Into My Arm Supernatural, Dean/Cas (1290): When a fast talking witch hexes Dean to get rid of all his scars, he's surprised to find that includes the handprint, too. It's not until Castiel shows up that he realizes just how much trouble they're actually in.
8)
Who If I Cried Out Would Hear Me Supernatural, Dean/Cas (1165): Dean goes missing on a hunt; Castiel can hear him but can't find him, and longer the situation drags on the unhappier Cas gets. An angry angel of the Lord is not someone to be messed with.
9)
Masks Upon Masks Kick-Ass, Mindy/OMC (1068): She knows what Mindy wants. She knows what Hit-Girl wants. She has no idea what the middle even is anymore.
10)
Cold And Sharp Supernatural, Dean/Cas (967): Dean came back from Hell with a taste for the rough stuff. Fortunately, Cas is willing to indulge him.
***
Stray thoughts - No surprise: SPN fandom loves its wing fic.:) And its smut, I
giggled when I saw that Cold And Sharp was in the top ten. Easily the kinkiest thing I've written. Also no surprise that virtually everything there is Supernatural (the only outlier is Masks Upon Masks, which was a Yuletide fic); my Doctor Who fic is a couple Doctors out of date now, and I think DW fandom still does a lot of reading on Teaspoon, L4D2 is tiny and mostly active on FF.Net and Heroes is mostly dead (and Peter/Claude was never close to a big pairing.) And I am freaking
delighted that Outrun My Gun and Look, Up In The Sky are in the top ten - I love those fics so, so much. Outrun was my first big bang-length fic (written in a month!) and Look was the first time I'd tried my hand at an AU fic (oh, my superhero boys. I have to carve out the time to write the sequel what lives in my head.)
It's really fascinating to see how reading patterns differ on LJ vs. AO3, too. Off the top of my head I would say that Who If I Cried Out and Exit Wounds are my two most popular fic on LJ, and while Who If I Cried Out was in the top ten it wasn't far and away #1 the way it is on LJ, and Exit Wounds isn't anywhere near the top. And Cold And Sharp is
way higher on AO3 than I would have ever expected. Interesting.
***
Back to the word mines.